What is a step up from the last 2-3 years, our MTE? I would argue that getting Marquette (even at Marquette) was a better MTE than what we have this year. Even if that was nothing more than inviting us to get a beat down, we still got a top 25 opportunity out of our MTE. We'll be lucky if we get a top 125 opportunity out of the one this year.
As far as other appearances, Davidson hasn't made a tournament since 2015, Bonaventure hasn't made it since 2021. Rhode Island hasn't made one since 2018. I'll give you Bonaventure, but URI has taken a nosedive. Even St Joes, who hasn't made it since 2016, seemingly gets better games (yes they have the Big5 but still).
There just has to be something to all of this. I'm not convinced its what we all think it is (value, ncaa appearances, etc).